Mueller Insurance Services
Insurance Agency in Fenton, MO
For all your Personal and Business Needs
WHO WE ARE
Your Experienced And Trusted Insurance Broker St. Louis Missouri
Finding the right insurance can be overwhelming. As a leading independent insurance broker in St. Louis, we simplify the process by comparing top providers to find the best coverage at the most competitive rates. Whether you’re looking for home and auto insurance Missouri, or need coverage for your home, car, or business, Mueller Insurance Services, LLC is here to help you secure the protection you deserve.
What Can We Do For You?
We’re an independent insurance agency. That means we can help you find the best coverage for your needs and budget, whether it’s liability only or full coverage. And because we work with a variety of companies, we can shop around to get you the best rates possible.

David has been an insurance agent for over 20 years. He will provide you with an excellent experience and is available at your convenience. Whether you need help insuring your first home, starting a business or it’s just time to consider other options, he knows what it takes to get you covered. Best of all, as an independent insurance agent in Fenton, MO, he has more options to fit your unique needs and budget.
OUR SERVICES
St. Louis Insurance Services
We offer a wide range of insurance solutions tailored to protect what matters most to you:
HOME INSURANCE
AUTO INSURANCE
BUSINESS INSURANCE
LIFE INSURANCE
WHY CHOOSE US
Why Choose Mueller Insurance Services, LLC?
Independent & Unbiased
As a St. Louis independent insurance agent, we work with multiple insurance carriers to find you the best rates and coverage.
Personalized Service
Unlike big corporations, we offer one-on-one assistance, ensuring you get customized policies that match your lifestyle and budget.
Affordable Rates
Our team compares multiple insurance companies in St. Louis to get you the most competitive pricing.
Local Expertise
We know the unique insurance needs of Missouri residents and businesses, making sure you are well protected.

Years of Experience
Home Insurance
Life Insurance
- Auto
- Home, Condo, Renters
- Earthquake
- Flood
- Landlord
- Classic Car
- Motorcycle
- Boat, RV and ATV
- Life Insurance
Business Insurance
- Workers Compensation
- Business Owners Policy
- General Liability
- Buildings and Property
- Directors & Officers
- Cyber Insurance
- Real Estate Investors
- Hospitality Industry
Auto Insurance
REVIEWS
What Our Clients Are Saying
kara2024-06-07Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. David is awesome to work with and answers all my questions and got back to me quickly. Taylor White2024-05-08Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. What an amazing staff and business! They were able to save me money, increase my coverage, and did it in a timely manner. Moreover, I was given options to consider. It never felt like a business decision, but more like a conversation with a friend. I have already reccomended many family members and friends to Mueller Insurance Services! Matt Hale2024-04-29Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. In 51 years on this planet. I have had dealings with several different people when it comes to insurance. I have never had a more enjoyable and positive experience than the last 18 months with Dave. He takes his work seriously and is very good at what he does!! Ashley Henley2024-04-16Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. David is so helpful! He is quick to respond and always there when we need him whether it be for home, car or our new business. Kyle Aubuchon2024-01-09Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Took great care of me on renter and auto. Very responsive and communicated everything perfectly. Plus saved me some cash! Alexander Emil2022-12-01Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. I’ve been insured by David Mueller for a year now and am extremely happy with his customer service. I actually got 3 quotes and paid a little more with him to get extra coverage. If you don’t understand insurance lingo, David does an excellent job of explaining everything. I’m very happy with the service provided and highly recommend him! Eric T.2022-08-19Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Meeting with David Mueller was a great experience. He was able to satisfy all of my insurance needs for both auto and home, as well as explain the details in a very understanding and comprehensive manner. He was extremely prompt with his responses, thorough and handled our business transaction in the utmost professional manner. I know he will be there for me and the rest of his loyal customers if they ever require assistance. I highly recommend visiting Mueller Insurance Services for your next policy. 👍👍 Thomas Lindley2022-07-01Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. I would give David 10 stars if you would let me. He was a pro when it came to helping me find the right coverage, and he went out of his way to find a great shop to repair my hail damage. He really cares about customer service. Anthony Delgado2022-07-01Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. David has been an honest, knowledgeable, and available resource for our family’s insurance needs. He was able to shop around with many providers to find the insurance policies that fit us best. Highly recommend.
Proud to Offer These Great Insurance Companies







FAQS
Frequently Asked Questions
No! In fact, working with an insurance broker in St. Louis can help you save money by comparing multiple policies from different providers to find the most cost-effective option.
Yes. An insurance agent typically works for one insurance company, while an insurance broker represents multiple providers, allowing them to find the best deals across the market.
Going with an independent insurance agency in St. Louis gives you more flexibility and better pricing options than working directly with a single insurance company.
You should prefer an independent insurance agent near you because they offer personalized service, access to multiple insurance options, competitive pricing, and ongoing support. Plus, their local knowledge can help you find the best coverage tailored to your needs, and they can assist you throughout the claims process.
Get Your St. Louis Insurance Quote Today
At Mueller Insurance Services, LLC, we are committed to providing top-notch customer service and ensuring you have the best insurance coverage at the best price. Whether you’re looking for home and auto insurance in Missouri, car insurance in Fenton, MO, or business insurance, we are here to help.
Get started today by requesting St. Louis insurance quotes and see how much you can save!